The State of indie guitar music 2012?

There has been much conjecture in the last few months of 2011 around the so called death of the guitar band with the X factor been blamed for bringing the genre to its knees by peddling huge volumes of manufactured talent less pop nonsense.

Recent rants by the likes of The Enemy and Kaiser Chiefs to name but two has highlighted fears that guitar music is well and truly on its arse and the last rites are been prepared for 2012.

Well our take on this is that in terms of the charts this could possibly be true to a certain extent, the charts are over populated by what can only be described as utter crap but as 2011ends we are actually looking at Coldplay been number one in the singles chart and Ed Sheeran been top of the pile in album sales, is that too bad? But those who are taking too much notice of the charts are missing a trick; on the whole the charts have always been for rubbish popularist music which tends to be over commercialised, obvious and low grade fare. It's there for a reason, to appeal to a certain sector of music buyers. Also to be fair to those of a certain vintage should cast their minds back to pre Britpop explosion days, prior to 1994 most 'indie guitar' bands singles charted at number 28 if they were popular and then dropped straight out of the top forty the following week if they were lucky. This actually was seen as a real measure of success by both artists and record companies alike and if they managed a spot on Top of the Pops then that was the cherry on the cake! The charts were then packed full of one hit wonders, pop, dance and manufactured boy bands… sound familiar?

Obviously the likes of Oasis changed all this and increased the public consumption of 'indie guitar' music. In fact taking the origins of the phrase 'indie' / 'indie guitar' / 'indie music' back to the late 1980's when a new wave of bands actually released records on independent record labels rather than the established vast major labels which concentrated on the likes of Madonna or Bon Jovi. The first batch of bands included the likes of The Cure (Fiction), The Smiths (Rough Trade) and Joy Division / New Order (Factory). The terms 'indie' or 'indie music' soon morphed away from the way music was released to the actual sound of the music, firstly the jangley sound of the likes of The Smiths and Leeds' The Wedding Present before morphing again with the 'indie guitar' bands in the post nineties era ranging from anything from Ocean Colour Scene, Kasabian and the aforementioned Enemy.

So despite the lack of so called chart success there's still bands playing stadiums, even in 2011 bands like Arctic Monkeys and Kasabian have shifted plenty of tickets on vast arena tours and the uber festivals still racked up profits despite mega ticket prices. There's venues up and down the countries putting bands on every single day, take Sheffield for example it has a huge array of excellent music venues ie the Soyo, Leadmill, Bowery and Academy easily named in seconds and then there's an arena plus University venues to boot too. Even in Doncaster we have a thriving live scene, probably the best selection of venues to choose from well ever really.

But have we one band that acts as leader of the genre, a band that really inspires a generation? Or do we have a movement, one that the NME and other publications can get behind, perhaps not. The split of Oasis has truth be told has left a vacuum that has yet to be filled. So where do we think the future of the genre lies in 2012? Well if it lacks that 'mega' band of say The Smiths or certainly Oasis will The Stone Roses re-entering the fold in 2012 be a catalyst to kick starts 1, bands coming through with the inspiration and aspiration to be the next 'Roses / Smiths / Oasis / Libertines and 2, kick start the peoples interest in music so after a trip to Heaton Park they look out for that next big band. That said it might just be a trip down memory lane but time will tell on that score. Still personally we feel there are loads of great bands out there at a local level who just need that 'break' to kick on nationally.

Are they been hampered by the current state of the record industry? Now we'd never thought we'd ever say this but has the internet actually killed the ability of record labels to propel the next big thing to superstar status. For one they no longer have the big A&R and publicity budgets nor does it seem they have the confidence to take the risks they used to do on indie music, tight budgets mean they play it safe and go for the easy pop option, a safe return on their cash outlay.

Playing it safe also brings us onto the controversial subject of the X Factor. Our take on the subject is somewhat unusual as we don't actually think that the show is the work of satan, nor do we think that Simon Cowell is the dark lord neither! Before the likes of the X Factor music on TV used to be sparse to put it mildly and it usually got booted into the late night graveyard shift slot, like Jools Holland's excellent Later show and had to be happy with it. X Factor has brought music well and truly into the primetime mainstream. Whilst most people who go onto the show tend to be talent less, attention seeking loses it doses now and again pop up somebody who can actually hold a tune in a bucket, not that they tend to win it like! They do also cover a load of crap but again they do pick some corkers and to those at home watching if only a small percentage go 'hey that's a good tune' and then search out the original version then that's good isn't it? If it then prompts them to go out and buy or download the album or go check out that artist live then job done. For example take the other year when the X Factor winner covered Hallelujah, sure the insipid version got to number one but look at all the people who downloaded and discovered the far superior Leonard Cohen or Jeff Buckley versions. Talking of superior versions, Biffy Cylro can really thank Matt Cardle and X factor for not only increasing their bank balance but also increasing their public profile too, their original version of 'Many of Horrors' was obviously loads better too!

So that's part of our view on the subject of the so called death of guitar music, yes we agree it does need a fresh injection of talent and purpose, it is missing that mega unit shifting figurehead that tends to drag up shed loads of bands on their coattails. But far from been dead on its arse, just listen to the likes of XFM or get down to a local venue you'll see and hear plenty of excellent bands. Aside from our views we want to find out what the up and coming talent think too, so we've done a 'State of indie music in 2012' Q&A and over the next few months it'll be mailed out to all and sundry to find out what they think too.

Colin

www.shaddersonline.com

January 2012.

So as soon as the ink is dry on our views on the 'State of Indie' then we get the first answers from the 'SOI 2012' Q&A from...

THE LINES

Yep some excellent responses too from Wolverhampton's finest, check it out on the drop down option from this very page.

January 2012.

Well as soon as The Lines Q&A was up and live we had another firmly in the bag. Again from the Midlands, this time youngsters ....

THE SET

Again the SOI 2012 Q&A is available from the drop down from this page. Enjoy!

January 2012.